A Strange and Stubborn Endurance by Foz Meadows: Book Review
š Genre | Fantasy, Romance |
š Number of Pages | 544 pages |
šŖ“ Average Goodreads Rating | 4.03ā |
š» My Rating | 2.5 ā |
Whatās A Strange and Stubborn Endurance About?
A Strange and Stubborn Endurance by Foz Meadows is a story about Velasin vin Aaro who is forced into a diplomatic marriage to a girl from another country. But then itās discovered he prefers men, and while his father wants to disown him for it, the other countryās envoy suggests marrying the brother of the girl he was supposed to marry. Though his new country, Tithena, seems great and freeing, and his new husband nice enough, Velasin is traumatized ā and more than that, thereās suddenly a threat on his life and the life of his new family.
Iāve been on a mission, recently, to find fantasy romance books that donāt fit the template of popular BookTok romantasies. You know, books that veer away from the standard tropes: teenage girls with extreme amounts of power, two love interests, one of whom is the villain and definitely her mate somehow, medieval-like kingdoms, and so on.
Because look ā I love fantasy. I love romance. Yet, somehow, Iāve been having no luck with fantasy romance because I keep running into the same things. Iām tired, and I need something new. And I refuse to give up on the genre.
If youāre keeping up, youāll know I discovered Your Blood, My Bones and loved it ā so Iād say Iāve been successful.Ā
Now, how does A Strange and Stubborn Endurance fit into this?
Well, itās a fantasy romance with no teenage girls and no villain-mates, so Iād say it fits the bill. Did I like it though? Iām still unsure.
The plot and the characters, as well as the romance, are quite refreshing. The love interest isnāt rude or brooding. Heās nice, sweet, very considerate. The romance is tender and gentle. The plot is a mystery with plenty of court politics, which I loved. All of the characters are fun, diverse, and involved. The world feels populated, and well-developed too ā no expositions or info-dumping, at least not egregiously so.
And while I appreciated those elements, I donāt think I liked the whole thing. A Strange and Stubborn Endurance, to me at least felt a bit plastic. A bit fake. I donāt know how to explain it.
So, Iāll start with a few things that I feel didnāt work, and hope it all makes sense in the end.
First of all, the rape scene. Because yes, thereās a rape scene and itās pretty graphic and happens really early on. So, be warned. I skimmed it hard because I cannot put myself through that.
Anyway ā that scene felt too much like a plot point. And I know what youāre going to say, of course itās a plot point, all of this is. But hear me out. It felt shoehorned in because otherwise, thereās barely any romantic conflict. If it was discovered Velasin was gay in a different way, Velasin and Caeās marriage would be simple, easy ā because they do like each other immediately. Thereād be no tension in the romance portion of the novel.
So yeah, it does feel like this character was put through this horrible thing just so he can have a reason not to fall in love with the love interest immediately.
Donāt get me wrong, the author handled it and the aftermath with care (well, somewhat, but Iāll get to that later), yet it felt gross because it was just trauma for the sake of the plot.
Plus, Iād argue it wasnāt necessary at all. Velasin could have been found just kissing his former boyfriend, as a sort of last goodbye, and it would have the same effect. The romantic conflict could have been Velasinās lack of confidence, the fact that he isnāt used to being openly with someone, his lingering feelings for his former lover, his feelings over being exiled from his family and former life. Any and all of the above.
Or, alternatively, hear me out ā we could have had Velasin go to Tithena ready to marry the lordās daughter, without being discovered, only to find himself falling in love with her brother. Thereās your conflict ā plenty of it.
But no, we went with the unnecessary rape instead.
And I get it, I do, that the author maybe wanted to say something about it. It just ā again, at least to me ā didnāt feel like it.
The whole plot of this book (including Velās three-week trip) takes place over a month, maybe. And Iām far from judging someone for moving on too quickly from trauma, but Velasin goes from trying to kill himself to being happily in love within a week. Which just confirms my thoughts that the assault was added for conflictās sake. Something to keep our main love interests apart for a little while.
I donāt know ā Iām not an expert on any of this, but as someone who has SA experiences, it didnāt feel right.
The world of A Strange and Stubborn Endurance is a diverse one, wonderfully so. I loved that we had a third gender, same sex relationships, transgender characters, and I wish more stories went in this direction.
However, the duality between Tithena (the āgoodā country) and Ralia (the ābadā, rigid society) struck me as a bit strange. These two countries are right next to each other, and have had trade agreements, wars, etc. How come none of Tithenaās progressiveness transferred to Ralia? Based on our world history, it would have ā clusters of nearby countries often share belief systems and culture due to centuries of intermingling. It would make more sense if there was more geographical distance between Ralia and Tithena.
Also, it felt as if this worldbuilding point was there for the author to have a chance to say things about our (real life) society. Which, on principle, I donāt mind, but the storytelling (and characters) felt a bit sock-puppety whenever the difference between two countries was mentioned.
Now, for the main mystery ā who is causing all the trouble, trying to kill/scare Vel and others? I wouldnāt say that it was predictable, because I had a feeling who it is but wasnāt sure. Yet, it felt wholly unnecessary and underdeveloped (so perhaps thatās why I feel it was unnecessary?).
Throughout the novel, things keep happening. This person is wounded, a horse is killed, messages are left, yet never do these characters get any closer to solving it. The mystery isnāt satisfying, especially because at the end, the characters just stumble into the solution (overhear the villain arguing with a co-conspirator).
It would have been better if Vel was the one to figure it, because one of his main traits is that heās smart.
The writing is at times clunky and overdone, but not bad. There are also two POVās here, Velasinās and Caeās, though Vel felt very much like the main character and Cae just the love interest. Because of that, his POV felt unnecessary ā we learn nothing interesting from Caeās perspective, other than how he feels about Vel.
And for this plot, this book was too long. I understand 500+ pages in epic fantasy with more detailed and complex plots, but this one could have been shaved down to 300 pages and it would be much tighter overall.
Overall, while I canāt say I didnāt enjoy A Strange and Stubborn Endurance at times, I also didnāt love it. It could have been a really good book, but the author made some choices that made it feel inorganic and disjointed. I hear it has a similar plot to a few other books, at least in parts, so I might try those out, but I wonāt continue reading this series.